If you’ve arrived here, you’re likely trying to choose between two icons of outdoor cooking. This is your side-by-side look at the Big Green Egg (BGE) and Weber.

These are two legendary brands with two very different approaches to grilling. We’re here to walk you through the pros and cons of each so you can decide which grill is right for you. 

Consider this your head-to-head breakdown of these iconic grill makers, complete with insights into design, cooking performance, portability, durability, and value. We’ll also show you where Kick Ash Basket grill accessories fit beautifully into each system.

Ready? Let’s fire things up.

History

Big Green Egg

Big Green Eggs are somewhat of a cult classic. Started in the 1970s and inspired by ancient Japanese kamado cookers, BGE grills have an unmistakable ceramic charm. These grills have a fierce fanbase, including our team. Many grillers name their Eggs and proudly refer to themselves as “Eggheads.”

Weber

If backyard cookouts had a national brand ambassador, it would be Weber. Weber is the OG backyard hero. George Stephen’s kettle grill hit the market in the early 1950s and changed the game as we know it. Today, Weber offers everything from kettles and gas grills to smokers, pellet rigs, and a full line of Weber grill accessories. 

Design & Build

Big Green Egg

BGE is known for the iconic curvy green aesthetic and feels like ancient cooking technology refined for modern fire nerds (and we say that with love).

Big Green Eggs feature thick ceramic walls that provide exceptional heat retention, making them naturally fuel-efficient and ideal for long, steady cooks. Their design also holds moisture remarkably well, which means juicy, delicious results no matter what you’re grilling.

Weber

Weber grills are designed to help you grill smarter, not harder. Their sleek, classic kettles deliver impressive airflow control and heat circulation. Built with lighter, simpler mechanisms, Weber grills are easy to move, use, and clean, making them a favorite for both grillmasters and newbies.

Cooking Style & Performance

Big Green Egg

Kamado cooking is all about control, and the Big Green Egg excels at it. It maintains steady low temperatures for classics like brisket, ribs, and pork shoulder, yet it can also reach impressively high searing temps. 

The thick ceramic construction offers naturally gentle, consistent heat retention, even in cold weather, giving you reliable performance year-round. The tradeoff is that cooking on a BGE can feel a bit like operating a high-performance sports car. It’s capable of incredible things, but it does come with a learning curve.

Weber

Weber grills are built for straightforward, dependable performance. They offer excellent airflow (especially in kettle models), deliver solid searing power, and provide generous cooking capacity for everything from weeknight dinners to big weekend gatherings. The kettle design makes it easy to hit and maintain temperatures without much fuss, which is a major advantage for newer grillers or those who just want a smoother experience. 

However, that convenience comes with a tradeoff. Compared to the insulated ceramic body of the Big Green Egg, Weber’s steel construction holds less heat, which means higher fuel consumption and reduced temperature stability.

Portability

Big Green Egg

When it comes to portability, the Big Green Egg is… committed to staying put. Its heavy ceramic construction gives it incredible heat retention, but that same weight makes it anything but travel-friendly. Moving a BGE is possible, but not overly convenient. It’s perfect for a permanent spot on your patio, but not ideal for camping trips, tailgates, or on-the-go adventures. 

Weber

When it comes to portable grilling, Weber wins here, hands down. From lightweight kettles to compact travel models, Weber grills are built to go wherever the party goes. Their steel construction keeps them light enough to transport easily while still offering excellent cooking performance. Whether you’re grilling at the park, tailgating, camping, or just moving your setup around the yard, Weber is a great portable option.

Durability

Big Green Egg

The Big Green Egg shines in durability thanks to its thick ceramic construction, which doesn’t rust, warp, or degrade the way metal can over time. That ceramic body delivers reliable performance and superior heat retention, even in cold weather like we get here in Wisconsin. 

That said, if your BGE gets tipped over or dropped, the ceramic can crack, turning a bad day into an even more expensive one. But treat it well, and it will outlive most grills on the market.

Weber

Weber grills are primarily made of steel and protected with modern coatings, so they hold up well over time. While they can be susceptible to rust if neglected, proper care keeps them performing well for years. 

One of Weber’s secret durability advantages is the availability of replacement parts. You can swap out grates, handles, and other parts as needed to extend the life of the grill. With routine maintenance, a Weber can serve you faithfully for years.

Value

Big Green Egg

The Big Green Egg sits in the premium grilling tier, and its price tag reflects that. You’re paying for the ceramic engineering, impressive moisture retention, and steady heat control that elevates your slow-smoked ribs, high-heat seared steaks, and other grilling masterpieces. 

For grillers who want a long-term investment and are ready to commit to a learning curve, the BGE’s performance justifies the cost. It’s less a purchase and more of a cooking tool investment. 

Weber

Weber offers some of the best value in the grilling world, delivering reliable performance across nearly every price range. Weber charcoal grills tend to give you remarkable capability for the cost. They’re user-friendly, durable, and versatile without requiring a big financial leap. For budget-conscious grillers or anyone looking to maximize performance per dollar, Weber is a smart choice.

Which Grill Is the Best?

So… which grill wins? Honestly, it depends on the kind of griller you are. 

The Big Green Egg delivers unmatched heat retention, incredible versatility, and competition-worthy results once you master its quirks. Weber, on the other hand, nails convenience, accessibility, and value. Their grills are easier to move, easier to learn, and easier to maintain while still delivering great results. 

At the end of the day, there’s no wrong answer — just the right grill for your style. And whichever team you land on, one thing’s guaranteed: the right Kick Ash accessories will boost airflow, simplify cleanup, and help your grill perform at its absolute best. 

Where Our Kick Ash Grill Accessories Fit In 

No matter which brand you choose, Kick Ash Basket keeps your fire happy.

Big Green Egg

We have grilling accessories for multiple BGE models, ranging from the mini 10-inch BGE all the way to the 2XL 29-inch model. Accessories including:

• Kick Ash Basket: Our baskets improve airflow for better cooking and make ash removal way easier. It’s a total game-changer. 

• Grill Divider: Dial in two-zone cooking on a kamado for delicious and faster results. 

• Kick Ash Can: Going hand-in-hand with the basket, the cans are a top-tier ash collection and removal solution. A must-have for BGE grillers! 

• Grill Drip Pans: Our drip pans help catch anything that falls to protect your grill. A cleaner BGE makes for better flavor and smoother cooking! 

See All Big Green Egg Grill Accessories

Weber Grills

Kick Ash Basket has high-quality grill accessories for Weber 18-inch kettle grills, Weber 22-inch kettle grills, and the Weber Summit. 

• KAB Ring of Fire & Divider: This setup turns your classic kettle into an airflow powerhouse improving cooking, cleanup, and allowing for easy dual zone cooking. 

• Drip Pans: Our stainless steel drip pans protect your kettle bowls and keep things tidy while you’re firing up something tasty.

• Grill Divider: Get flawless two-zone cooking on your Weber and take your grilling techniques to the next level.  

See All Weber Grill Accessories

Become a Grill Master 

Did you know Kick Ash Basket has custom created grill accessories for some of the top grill brands? If you’re ready to up your grill game, let’s go. 

Shop By Grill Now

Looking for other grill comparisons? Let's find the right grill brand for you. 

• Weber vs PK

• Vision vs Big Green Egg Grill

• Big Green Egg vs. Kamado Joe Grill

• Which Charcoal Grill is Best for You?